My FiancÚ and I stayed at Lucy's Cottage in September 2002, and we loved it so much we are thinking of moving to Kefalonia in the future.
We still miss the boat waking us up at 0900 every morning, being able to walk 3 minutes and be in the med.
The apartment was small, but had everything we needed, and a whole lot of character to boot. Just far enough from the town to be quiet, close enough to walk. In one simple work - WOW . . . . .